On November 7, before Michigan played Michigan State in Ann Arbor, fans of both schools lined up at yurts on the golf course and donated 237 gallons of urine to a fertilizer research project. Michigan fans supplied 137 gallons. Michigan State fans supplied 100.
The event was run by Nancy Love's N‑E‑W Cycles Group in Civil and Environmental Engineering at Michigan, with collaborators at Michigan State. It borrowed its name from an annual contest at the Rich Earth Institute in Vermont, which also collaborated. Of the donors, 1,097 marked a tally for their team. The yurts held urinals only, so every donor was someone who could use one standing up. The organizers call it the first stadium scale pilot of its kind in the United States and hope to repeat it in East Lansing next year.
The urine will be pasteurized, concentrated about sixfold by freezing and thawing, and split into a concentrated liquid that carries the nitrogen and solid struvite pellets that hold phosphorus and potassium. The fertilizer goes to field plots at Michigan's Matthaei Botanical Gardens and Michigan State's Kellogg Biological Station. The team has until spring to process it.
WAiR last visited this subject on January 10, 2022, when the Rich Earth Institute's existence was the news and the open question was the logistics of collecting and aggregating the raw material. Michigan's answer to the logistics question is a football crowd.
Urine is 91 to 96 percent water. The rest is about 59 grams of dissolved solids a day, and more than half of that is urea. Urea is how the liver packages the nitrogen left over from protein metabolism so the kidney can excrete it. About 85 percent of urinary nitrogen leaves as urea, 5 percent as ammonia, and the remaining 10 percent as creatinine, uric acid and other organic compounds.
The daily nitrogen figure in the engineering literature is about 11 grams. By the standard nutrition conversion (6.25 grams of protein per gram of nitrogen) that is the residue of roughly 70 grams of dietary protein. A nephrologist reads a 24 hour urea nitrogen as a diet history. An agronomist reads it as a fertilizer analysis.
| Constituent | Per day | Per year | Form |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volume | about 1.4 L | about 500 L | Range 0.6 to 2.6 L a day. 100 to 150 gallons a year. |
| Nitrogen | about 11 g | about 4 kg | Mostly urea. Becomes ammonia on storage. |
| Phosphorus | about 1 g | about 0.4 kg | Dissolved phosphate, directly available to plants. |
| Potassium | about 2.5 g | about 1 kg | Free ion. |
| Also present | Sodium, chloride, sulfate, magnesium, calcium, trace metals at low levels, and whatever drugs and metabolites the donor is clearing. Fresh pH is about 6.2. | ||
The case for separating urine rests on one disproportion. Urine is about 1 percent of the volume of household wastewater and carries most of its nutrients.
A treatment plant spends energy removing that nitrogen from a large volume of water. A fertilizer plant spends energy putting nitrogen into urea. Ammonia synthesis runs on natural gas and accounts for somewhere between 1 and 2 percent of world energy use. Friedrich Wöhler made urea in a flask in 1828, which is usually counted as the first laboratory synthesis of a compound from a living body. It is now the most widely applied nitrogen fertilizer in the world.
The chemistry that makes urine awkward to recycle starts within hours. Bacterial urease splits urea into ammonia and carbonate. The pH climbs toward 9. Ammonia escapes as gas, which is the smell of a neglected restroom and also the nitrogen leaving. Minerals precipitate and scale the pipes. Every treatment method on the market is a way of managing that one reaction. Some let it finish in a sealed tank. Some block it with acid or with alkali. Some hand the ammonia to nitrifying bacteria and convert half of it to nitrate.
An adult produces 100 to 150 gallons a year. The Piss Off collected about what two adults make annually, from more than a thousand people in an afternoon.
| Yardstick | Source figure | 237 gallons covers |
|---|---|---|
| Hay | Rich Earth uses about 1,000 gallons per acre, supplying roughly 50 pounds of nitrogen | About a quarter of an acre |
| Corn | Illinois recommendations for 2026 ran 180 to 200 pounds of nitrogen per acre | About 6 percent of an acre |
| Nitrogen | Roughly 50 pounds per 1,000 gallons at full strength | About 12 pounds, or 5 kilograms |
As a fertilizer supply, the haul is small. The team describes the day as a test of collection procedures and a way to reach the public, and the State News reported that it served both purposes. Love's own campus estimate is the more useful number. She figures that capturing as little as 4 percent of the urine flushed by Michigan's students, faculty and staff would let the university stop buying fertilizer.
| Where | Method | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Vermont Rich Earth Institute | Donors bring jugs to a depot. Urine is pasteurized and spread on hay. | Running since 2012, when 60 donors gave 600 gallons. Now more than 12,000 gallons a year under a state permit. Home of the original Piss Off. |
| Michigan N‑E‑W Cycles | Diverting toilets in one campus building, now stadium urinals. Pasteurize, freeze concentrate, precipitate struvite. | Research scale. Products labeled through the state agriculture department. Trials on gardens and research plots, with food crops described as future work. |
| Switzerland Eawag and Vuna | Nitrification, activated carbon to strip drug residues, then distillation. 1,000 liters of urine yields about 100 liters of fertilizer. | The product, Aurin, was approved for edible crops by the Swiss agriculture office in 2018, then in Liechtenstein (2019) and Austria (2022). |
| Sweden SLU, Gotland | Alkaline dehydration. Fresh urine is dried on an alkaline medium into a solid of about 10 percent nitrogen, 1 percent phosphorus and 4 percent potassium. | Pilot. Pellets fertilized barley that went to a brewery. |
| France Paris and Bordeaux | Diverting toilets plumbed to a neighborhood treatment unit. Separately, Toopi Organics ferments collected urine into a microbial biostimulant. | The Saint‑Vincent‑de‑Paul district (about 600 homes) is due to open in early 2027. The 600 meters of dedicated piping cost about one million euros. |
| South Africa Durban, Cape Town | Durban's dry toilets were the first large rollout and the origin of the Swiss process. A Cape Town startup stabilizes urine and concentrates it by reverse osmosis. | The startup recovers about 70 percent of the water and was shortlisted for the 2026 Africa Prize for Engineering Innovation. |
| Niger Maradi, Tillabery | Women farmers store urine to sanitize it, dilute it 1 to 1, and apply it by hand to pearl millet. They named the product Oga. | 681 on farm trials, 2014 to 2016. Yield rose about 30 percent over usual practice. More than a thousand farmers adopted it. |
Rich Earth's 2014 hay trials found no significant difference in yield among diluted urine, undiluted urine and synthetic fertilizer applied at the same nitrogen rate. A Finnish barley trial reported grain and straw yields equivalent to mineral fertilizer. The nutrients are already dissolved in the forms plants take up.
What to keep in mindThese are small trials on hay, barley and millet. The Niger result compares urine with the farmers' usual practice on poor soil, which is closer to no fertilizer than to a synthetic control. At least one press summary reported it as a win over commercial fertilizer on wheat, and both details were wrong.
Prithvi Simha at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences estimated that humanity's urine holds enough to replace about a quarter of current nitrogen and phosphorus fertilizer. Nature repeated it in a 2022 feature. A Stanford group puts urinary nitrogen at about 14 percent of annual fertilizer demand. Love's figure for Michigan is 20 to 25 percent of the nitrogen needed for grass, flowers and other plants nobody eats.
What it assumesEvery one of these is a ceiling. It assumes all urine is captured, none of the nitrogen is lost as ammonia, and the product reaches a field that needs it. The estimates also differ by nearly twofold.
A 2020 Michigan life cycle assessment compared conventional wastewater treatment with two city scale diversion designs. Diversion lowered greenhouse gas emissions by 29 to 47 percent, energy use by 26 to 41 percent, freshwater use by about half, and nutrient pollution by 25 to 64 percent. Avoided fertilizer manufacture and lighter treatment loads outweighed the trucking and processing.
The fine printThe systems modeled do not exist anywhere. The analysis covers operations, so the cost of replumbing buildings is outside it. One of the two fertilizer methods consistently increased acidification. Love is a coauthor, and the work was funded by the National Science Foundation and the Water Research Foundation.
A six year collaboration among Rich Earth, Michigan and the University at Buffalo spiked urine fertilizer with pharmaceuticals at the highest concentrations in the literature and at ten times that, then grew lettuce. The lettuce took up between 0.00004 and 0.0002 percent of the applied drug mass. Eating such vegetables daily for 70 years would deliver at most 2.5 percent of one therapeutic dose. Exposure was no different from crops irrigated with reclaimed water, which people already eat.
What is openThe authors include Rich Earth's cofounder and Love. The long term effect on soil and soil microbes is still under study in a five year trial with Cornell. Pasteurization kills pathogens and leaves drug molecules intact, although one news report on the Piss Off said it removes them. Activated carbon does remove them. The Swiss process includes that step, Rich Earth's does not, and the Piss Off website does not address the question. Freeze concentration would be expected to concentrate whatever is dissolved.
Bacteria in urine die during storage as ammonia accumulates, and they release their DNA, resistance genes included. A 2020 Michigan study added resistance plasmids to urine aged 12 to 16 months and tested whether a common soil bacterium could take them up. Within 24 hours the plasmids lost more than 99 percent of their ability to transform it.
The fine printOne plasmid, two resistance genes, one recipient species, in a laboratory. The gene copies were still detectable by PCR. They had been cut and could no longer transfer. The finding applies to aged urine. In fresh urine the DNA remained usable.
One product approved for food crops in three European countries. One permitted community program in Vermont. A diverting toilet from a large Swiss manufacturer that looks and works like an ordinary one. One Paris district about to open.
What does notNo city runs on it. Eawag, which put diverting toilets in its own headquarters in 2005, describes urine separation as a change that works only when toilets, plumbing, treatment, regulators and farmers line up together, and says the toilet proved the hardest part. Liquid urine is heavy. Fertilizing a hectare takes about 15 tonnes of it, against about 400 kilograms once dried. In findings Rich Earth presented at its 2025 field day, most respondents preferred to see it used on crops people do not eat.
| Product | How | Where it stands |
|---|---|---|
| Drinking water | Vacuum distillation, with a brine processor added to recover the remainder. | In service. The International Space Station reached 98 percent total water recovery in 2023, up from 93 to 94 percent. |
| Fertilizer for space crops | The Swiss nitrification and distillation process, adapted by a European Space Agency program. | Research. The agency's Paris headquarters has diverting toilets. |
| Ammonium sulfate, off grid | A Stanford prototype uses solar electricity to pull ammonia across membranes and uses the panel's waste heat to speed the last step. | Laboratory prototype (Nature Water, August 2025). The team's model values the output at up to $4.13 per kilogram of nitrogen in Uganda, more than double the United States figure. |
| Solid peroxide | An electrochemical cell converts urea into percarbamide, a crystalline carrier of hydrogen peroxide used in bleaching and disinfection. | Laboratory (Nature Catalysis, January 2025). Near 100 percent purity reported from human and animal urine. |
| Bone mineral | An engineered yeast breaks down urea, raises the pH and secretes hydroxyapatite, the calcium phosphate of bone and teeth. | Laboratory (Nature Communications, 2025). About one gram per liter in under a day. The authors estimate a cost near $19 per kilogram against a sale price of $50 to $200. |
| Hormones | Purification of gonadotropins that the kidney filters into urine. | In clinical use since the 1960s. Menotropins come from the urine of postmenopausal women and urinary hCG from the urine of pregnant women. Recombinant versions exist alongside them. |
The argument for local fertilizer had a good year. After shipping through the Strait of Hormuz was disrupted in late February, urea passed $850 a metric ton in April, up 80 percent in two months and the highest price since April 2022, according to the World Bank. The Middle East supplies close to a quarter of world urea exports. About 17 percent of the urea used in the United States comes from the Gulf. The Bank expects prices to ease in 2027 as exports recover.
A fertilizer whose feedstock arrives daily in every town is insulated from a shipping lane. It is exposed instead to plumbing codes, state permits and the willingness of people to change toilets. The Michigan team's own reading is that rural communities in the state are the best first fit.
Nancy Love has led urine recycling research at Michigan for about a decade. Her group and its partners received a $3 million National Science Foundation grant in 2016. The freeze concentration process was developed with Brightwater Tools, a company spun out of the Rich Earth Institute that licenses Michigan patents, and the university has a financial interest in it. The event website discloses this. A diverting toilet for seated and standing users is also headed to market, according to Michigan State's announcement.
Rich Earth is a nonprofit whose mission is to promote the practice. It is also a coauthor on the main safety study and the parent of the company that sells the equipment. Aurin is sold by a spinoff of the Swiss institute that developed and tested it. The yield figures for Toopi Organics come from the company.
None of this is hidden and none of it is unusual for a field this small. It does mean the safety and yield literature has been written largely by the people building the systems. The Piss Off shirts are $22.
The chemistry is settled. Urine is a dilute solution of the same urea that factories make from natural gas, and it grows hay, barley and millet about as well. The open questions are plumbing, permits, trucking and whether anyone wants it on lettuce.
The Piss Off collected a quarter acre's worth of nitrogen and a week of national sports coverage. For a field whose main obstacle is getting people to talk about it, that is the better yield.
Sources
The event: Housman A. U‑M Celebrates Victory Against MSU at Inaugural Piss Off Competition. Michigan Civil and Environmental Engineering, 13 November 2026. cee.engin.umich.edu
Event website (process, partners, Brightwater disclosure): The Piss Off. pissoff.engin.umich.edu
Tallies: In this UM-MSU pissing contest, Michigan beats Michigan State. The Detroit News, 8 November 2026. detroitnews.com
Next steps, processing timeline: Michigan, MSU fans donate 237 gallons of urine at 'Piss Off' for fertilizer research. The State News, November 2026. statenews.com
Alcohol and dilution, the 4 percent campus estimate: A rivalry with benefits: U-M, MSU to turn fans' pee into fertilizer. Detroit Free Press via Yahoo, November 2026. yahoo.com
The 20 to 25 percent estimate, food crops as future work: CBS Detroit, 5 November 2026. cbsnews.com
Michigan State announcement (toilet, Rich Earth model): MSU College of Social Science, 4 November 2026. sociology.msu.edu
Urinals only: UM-MSU rivalry now includes urine collection for fertilizer research. FOX 2 Detroit via Yahoo. yahoo.com
Composition: Rose C, Parker A, Jefferson B, Cartmell E. The Characterization of Feces and Urine. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol. 2015;45(17):1827-1879. PMC4500995
Share of wastewater, nitrogen forms: Martin TMP, Esculier F, Levavasseur F, Houot S. Human urine-based fertilizers: A review. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol. 2020. doi.org/10.1080/10643389.2020.1838214
Per person annual values, barley trial: Viskari E-L et al. Nitrogen Recovery With Source Separation of Human Urine. Front Sustain Food Syst. 2018. frontiersin.org
Overview, the one quarter estimate, barriers: Wald C. The urine revolution: how recycling pee could help to save the world. Nature. 2022;602:202-206. nature.com
Rich Earth program: Urine Nutrient Reclamation Program. richearthinstitute.org. Gallons per acre and per person: Greenfield Recorder. recorder.com
Hay trials: SARE project ONE14-218 final report. projects.sare.org
Corn nitrogen rates, United States dependence on Gulf urea: farmdoc daily, University of Illinois, April 2026. farmdocdaily.illinois.edu
Life cycle assessment: Hilton SP, Keoleian GA, Daigger GT, Zhou B, Love NG. Environ Sci Technol. 2021;55(1):593-603. doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.0c04195
Pharmaceutical uptake: Rodriguez EE et al. Comparative Exposure Assessment of Crops Grown by Urine-Derived Fertilizer and Crops Irrigated with Reclaimed Water. 2025. richearthinstitute.org. Treatment options and the 2025 farmer findings: Fertilizing with urine: is it safe?
Antibiotic resistance genes: Goetsch HE, Love NG, Wigginton KR. Fate of Extracellular DNA in the Production of Fertilizers from Source-Separated Urine. Environ Sci Technol. 2020;54:1808-1815. pubs.acs.org
Switzerland: Eawag. Aurin, fertilisers from urine. eawag.ch. On the difficulty of toilets: eawag.ch
Sweden: Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. Can urine help save food production during crises? 2022. slu.se
Paris: Hydroplus, March 2025, via the OCAPI program. leesu.fr. Opening date: RFI via inkl. inkl.com. Toopi Organics: cordis.europa.eu
South Africa: Urine-based system targets nutrient recovery. Engineering News, 1 May 2026. engineeringnews.co.za
Niger: Moussa HO et al. Sanitized human urine (Oga) as a fertilizer auto-innovation from women farmers in Niger. Agron Sustain Dev. 2021;41:56. link.springer.com
Forward osmosis: University of Surrey, 14 April 2026. surrey.ac.uk
Space station water: Space.com, June 2023. space.com. European Space Agency program: business.esa.int
Solar ammonia recovery: Stanford Report, August 2025 (Coombs et al., Nature Water). news.stanford.edu
Percarbamide: Shi X et al. In situ electrochemical production of solid peroxide from urine. Nat Catal. 2025;8:67-78. doi.org/10.1038/s41929-024-01277-3
Hydroxyapatite: UC Irvine News, June 2025 (Nature Communications). news.uci.edu. Cost estimate: Berkeley Lab via Newswise
Urinary gonadotropins: Menopur summary of product characteristics. medicines.org.uk
Fertilizer prices: World Bank Data Blog. Fertilizer prices surge as Strait of Hormuz disruptions tighten supplies. 2026. blogs.worldbank.org