A Men's Health article pointed toward what appears to be a significant increase in ticks and tickborne illness. A fair bit of anti-science rhetoric has been rolled into the story. I had Claude put together an analysis of the readily available resources, including reports, studies and histories of tickborne illness, and checked them against the claims that various online scientists and conspiracy theorists have laid out.
Six claims are graded below. Click any one to jump to it.
- Lyme disease was created in a lab
- The military experimented on ticks under a former Nazi scientist
- Vaccine makers are dropping boxes of ticks on farms
- Bill Gates engineered ticks to make Americans allergic to meat
- Ticks are getting worse
- So it's all climate change
There is also a timeline of how old Lyme disease is and a short list of talking points.
| When | Evidence |
|---|---|
| 60,000+ yrs | Whole genome sequencing of 148 Borrelia burgdorferi samples puts the bacterium's family tree in North America at least this far back, long before humans crossed the Bering land bridge (Walter et al., Nature Ecology & Evolution, 2017). |
| 5,300 yrs | Ötzi, the Alpine Iceman, carried B. burgdorferi DNA. He is the oldest known human case (Keller et al., Nature Communications, 2012). |
| 1896 | Museum mice collected on Cape Cod test positive for the bacterium. |
| 1945 | Museum ticks from eastern Long Island test positive, years before any research began on Plum Island. |
| 1969 | A Lyme case in Spooner, Wisconsin, in a patient who had never left the area. That is about 1,000 miles from Plum Island. |
| 1975 to 1976 | A cluster of childhood arthritis in Lyme, Connecticut gives the disease its name. |
| 1982 | Willy Burgdorfer identifies the spirochete in deer ticks from Shelter Island and publishes in Science. |
Sam Telford, a Tufts infectious disease professor who did the museum specimen work as a graduate student, has pointed out the timing problem. Any lab manipulation would have had to happen after the organism was identified in 1981, by which point infected ticks had been in drawers for decades. The population genetics also argue against a single recent release. Bacteria from the Northeast, the Midwest and California are separated by old geographic barriers, which a leak from one island would not produce.
The bacterium is ancient on two continents. The Yale genomic work found no recent introduction and no mutation that made it more transmissible. The modern epidemic tracks changes in the landscape. Nothing in the organism itself changed.
What the theory requiresA lab that worked faster than evolution and retroactively infected mice in 1896.
The United States did study insects and ticks as disease vectors during the Cold War, and Erich Traub, a German virologist, came over through Operation Paperclip. Fort Terry on Plum Island hosted military biological research until the USDA took it over in 1954 to study livestock disease. Nixon ended the offensive program in 1969. The FY2026 defense authorization, signed in December 2025 after Rep. Chris Smith pushed similar language for years, directs the GAO to review federal tick experiments from 1945 to 1972. That report is still pending.
Where it breaksAn agricultural spokeswoman said in 2004 she knew of no connection between Traub and Plum Island, and Homeland Security, which later ran the island, says it never studied Lyme. Kris Newby, whose 2019 book Bitten revived the theory, told PolitiFact she has never said Lyme is a bioweapon. Her claim is narrower, that weaponized ticks accelerated its spread. The Washington Post disputed whether a key source in her book was a bioweapons researcher at all. Lyme is also a poor weapon. It incubates slowly, rarely kills, and does not take soldiers off a battlefield quickly. A GAO review of old files is a records search. It is not evidence of anything until it reports.
Snopes traced the spring 2026 version to an Iowa herbalist with a doctorate from an unaccredited school. Her March video about farmers finding boxes of ticks drew more than 10 million views and came with a supplement based tick prevention guide. Snopes contacted hundreds of Missouri health and government officials. None had seen a box. Wolfe reshared the video on Telegram.
The boxes that do exist are bait boxes, which entomologist Erika Machtinger of Penn State notes are designed to kill ticks on mice, not release them. Many viral clips show Sherman live traps with ants scattering out. Ticks do not swarm.
The motive problemThe supposed beneficiary is the Pfizer and Valneva Lyme vaccine, which reported about 70 percent efficacy but technically missed its trial endpoint because too few participants caught Lyme. A company hoping to show efficacy would want more ticks during the trial. The plot arrived a year late. The last human Lyme vaccine, LYMErix, was withdrawn in 2002 after a wave of unproven safety fears and lawsuits, and there has been none since.
First, the Gates Foundation has funded work on the Asian blue cattle tick, a livestock pest. Second, in 2012 NYU bioethicist Matthew Liao coauthored a philosophy paper on “human engineering” for climate change that floated induced meat intolerance as a thought experiment. In later talks he pointed to alpha-gal syndrome as a natural example.
Why they don't connectIn the United States, alpha-gal syndrome comes mostly from the lone star tick, a different species from the one in the Gates funded work. Liao's paper proposed pills and patches, not ticks, and was widely mocked by climate advocates at the time. PolitiFact and others rated the Gates claim false.
This is the part the conspiracy theorists get right. In late April the CDC reported that emergency visits for tick bites in four of its five regions were the highest for that time of year since tracking began in 2017, and they stayed elevated into June. Positive alpha-gal tests have risen roughly 100 fold since 2013. Anaplasmosis rose 16 fold from 2000 to 2017. In Maine, winter ticks have killed up to 90 percent of tracked moose calves in some recent years.
The caveatEmergency visits measure people, not ticks. They also rise with awareness, more time outdoors and readier care seeking. Machtinger makes exactly this point. Reported Lyme cases also jumped after the CDC simplified its surveillance case definition in 2022. The direction is clear. The precise size of this year's surge is less so.
Warmer winters speed the tick life cycle and let blacklegged ticks survive farther north each year, by one Yale estimate about 28 miles. Springs come earlier, so ticks come out earlier. Reported Lyme in Canada rose from 144 cases in 2009 to 917 in 2015 as the tick moved into Ontario, Quebec and the Maritimes. Modeling in Quebec found that temperature sets the northern limit of the bacterium, with fragmented habitat shaping it locally.
What climate didn't startThe original epidemic in the Northeast was a land use story. Farms were abandoned and forests grew back. Deer rebounded in a landscape without wolves and with limited hunting. Then suburbs filled the forest edges with white-footed mice and people. Richard Ostfeld of the Cary Institute, who has studied this for decades, has said the relative weight of climate and habitat change is still poorly understood. Climate is the accelerant. The fire was lit by how we rebuilt the eastern landscape.
The true explanation has acorns in it. Ostfeld's own work ties tick risk to big acorn years, mouse booms the following year, infected nymphs the year after that, deer density, forest fragmentation and winter temperatures, interacting in ways that differ by county. He told Grist he worries that explanations even this complicated may now be too much for people to absorb.
The conspiracy version has a villain, a motive and a product. Machtinger's observation is that misinformation fills the space where concern is high and good solutions are scarce. With no vaccine, a CDC that cannot say why this spring was bad, and an ACIP tied up in litigation, the space is wide open. Emory infectious disease researcher Laurel Bristow put the commercial side plainly. “There's no evidence that anything they're selling will reduce your risk.”
The Tick Invasion Solutions Summit was free to attend.
- The Lyme bacterium is at least 60,000 years old in North America and was in a 5,300 year old European mummy. Nobody invented it.
- The military did study ticks as vectors. The GAO is reviewing the files. A records review is not a finding.
- No one has produced a single box of released ticks. The real boxes kill ticks.
- Alpha-gal in the U.S. comes from the lone star tick, not the cattle tick Gates money studied.
- Ticks really are worse. Land use started the epidemic. Climate is extending its season and pushing it north.
- What works is dull. EPA registered repellent, permethrin treated clothing, tick checks, removal within 24 hours, and a doctor visit for rash or fever.
We cut down the eastern forests, let them grow back, killed the wolves, protected the deer, built houses at the tree line and warmed the winters. Each step was reasonable on its own. Together they made a near perfect tick habitat. The ticks didn't need a Nazi. They had us.
Sources
Prompt: Cassidy Randall, “The Great American Tick Invasion Is Here. So Are the Conspiracy Theories.” Men's Health, November 2026 (read in excerpt via Apple News).
Climate and conspiracies: Zoya Teirstein, “Climate change is driving a tick boom. MAHA is blaming Bill Gates.” Grist, May 14, 2026. grist.org (republished by PreventionWeb and Popular Science)
Tick box rumor and vaccine: Anna Merlan, “An Unreleased Lyme Disease Vaccine Is Already Sparking False Conspiracy Theories.” Mother Jones, May 1, 2026. motherjones.com
Bait boxes and ER data caveat: Nikki Blunier, “Tick Misinformation: When Real Science Becomes a Rumor” (Erika Machtinger, Penn State). IPM Institute, August 2026. ipminstitute.org
Bioweapon timeline: Sam Telford, “No, Lyme disease is not an escaped military bioweapon.” The Conversation via Popular Science, July 2019. popsci.com
Genomic age: Walter KS et al., “Genomic insights into the ancient spread of Lyme disease across North America.” Nature Ecology & Evolution, 2017. Yale summary: ysph.yale.edu
The Iceman: Keller A et al., Nature Communications, 2012. Summary: Scientific American
Newby and Plum Island: PolitiFact, “Was Lyme disease spread as a bioweapon?” May 16, 2024. politifact.com; Lead Stories, April 2022. leadstories.com
GAO review: Rep. Chris Smith, FY26 NDAA amendment text. chrissmith.house.gov; E&E News, “Defense bill directs GAO to probe tick conspiracy.” eenews.net
Gates and alpha-gal: PolitiFact, September 1, 2023. politifact.com; Liao, Sandberg and Roache, “Human Engineering and Climate Change,” Ethics, Policy & Environment, 2012.
CDC ER data: CDC Tick Bite Data Tracker and April 2026 advisory, as reported by States Newsroom; case definition change via JUCM.
Climate versus land use: Simon JA et al., climate and habitat fragmentation at the northern limit of B. burgdorferi. PMC; Canada Communicable Disease Report, 2019. PMC; Ostfeld interview, PBS NewsHour; Canada case counts, EHP.
The summit: David Wolfe, “The Tick Invasion Solutions Summit Is ON.” Substack, July 2026. substack.com